FDP Forum / Here we go again - Martin HD-28 or HD-28V? - two year update 12/28/16/ 387 messages in thread.

381 to 387 of 387 shown.
First Page Previous 20


jvstratman

Contributing Member
*******

USA

Feb 3rd, 2017 05:21 AM        

I used to be a Boutique snob but have come to the realization of just how damn good Martin guitars are. I raise my glass! To Martin!!



reverend mikey

Contributing Member
**********
*

N of I-90, E of I-29

"Everywhere I look, I see guitars..."
Feb 3rd, 2017 10:41 AM        

I just bought a mint 2012 D-18 Standard (the updated version) and it is an amazing guitar. It quickly became my #2, in front of my 2015 D-35/50 Standard which I bought new.<br /> <br /> I'm fine with the neck profile on this one - sometimes V necks hurt my hand, but I haven't played all of Martin's V's... the rest of the guitar is just gorgeous in it's simplicity with it's toner top and tortoise body binding and old style headstock logo. <br /> <br /> And the sound... oh my... so woody and punchy and good volume, and it's just a few years old! As I said, it's #2; the only guitar in front of it is my hog 25 year old Larrivee OM - that guitar has matured to have a rich tone all across the strings that I haven't heard in too many guitars I've played in person.<br /> <br /> I'm already thinking about my "next Martin," either an M-36 (0000 size with a 3-piece rosewood back) or a custom 0000 with a hog body and the D-18's appointments and an identical D-18 neck profile (with 1 3/4" nut). Drool...



budg

Contributing Member
**********

ohio

Home of the Goodyear blimp
Feb 3rd, 2017 02:51 PM        

Rev , I m with you . I had my heart set on a D18GE . I had a 2010 D18 that I just wasnt happy with. I decided before I spent 3k on the GE I needed to at least try the new D18 .I did and I decided to purchase it instead of the GE. It has great projection and tone . Much better than the old straight braced D18s . Its a beautiful guitar to boot. Love the neck too.



rc

Contributing Member
*

US

Feb 3rd, 2017 04:19 PM        

not a dread but I go back and forth between a 000-18GE (V neck) and a plain ole 00-15 (1 11/16 roundish neck) with zero problems. both play like butta.



Viera

Contributing Member
**********
******

Santee CA

Poser extraordinaire
Feb 3rd, 2017 05:41 PM        

Speaking of D-18s: I've been very fortunate to have owned some nice acoustics in recent years. The best for me was a 2005 D-18GE. The shop I bought it from, Buffalo Bros (God I miss that place), had 6 of them in stock. I got my pick of the litter. 3 of the 6 I could have bought. The one I went with was truly special. <br /> <br /> I stupidly sold it about 3 years ago. I was having some shoulder issues and convinced myself to go with a 000 or OM sized acoustic. Of all the guitars I've bought and sold that D-18GE is the only one that still haunts me. Fortunately I lucked into a great Gibson Advanced Jumbo a couple of years ago at a going out of business sale (Guitar Trader, God, I miss that place). <br /> <br /> There's just nothing like a good forward shifted scalloped braced dread.



Chris Greene

FDP Host

Idaho, USA

I need a drink and a quick decision
Feb 3rd, 2017 06:49 PM        

The thing that makes me occasionally think of a D18 is listening to older recordings of Ron Block (AKUS) playing his. Damn, that thing has a great sound.



6L6

Contributing Member
**********
**********
*****

San Francisco, CA

May 10th, 2017 11:17 AM        

As Beal likes to say, "You can't make up for lack of talent with bling, but I try anyway!"<br /> <br /> Me too.<br /> <br /> I LOVE bling! Every D-42 I've ever played (owned a '97 once) has been stellar to look at and I love the FSSB tone.<br /> <br /> In a perfect world I'd own a Pre War D-45 with block inlays. Right now I'm about $400K short of accomplishing that.<br /> <br /> 6



Chris Greene

FDP Host

Idaho, USA

Nine mile skid on a ten mile ride
Oct 25th, 2017 06:21 PM        

I don't know why I keep thinking of D-45's but I do. I called Cros and asked if he'd part with one of his three but he told me f off.



Hammond101

Contributing Member
**********
*

So. Cal. USA

Oct 26th, 2017 09:44 AM        

I think the bling helps your attitude and you may actually play better. Nah......



pombrio



USA

Oct 26th, 2017 11:28 AM        

I want to try out the redesigned standard series Martin D-28 for 2017 to see how it compares to the HD-28 and HD-28V. The new D-28 now has forward shifted bracing, although it's still non-scalloped.



Chris Greene

FDP Host

Idaho, USA

Nine mile skid on a ten mile ride
Oct 26th, 2017 11:52 AM        

I'd like to try the new D-28 too although with the HD-28V, I think my D-28 jones has been met.



Hammond101

Contributing Member
**********
*

So. Cal. USA

Oct 26th, 2017 01:48 PM        

I've been checking out every guitar store in SoCal checking out Martin dreads. So far the only one I would have considered buying was a D-18E at The Fret House in Covina.<br /> <br /> I just don't like they way they come out of the box. They sound like cardboard to me. The action is not at all correct. This would include 28s, 35s, herringbones and vintage series. I guess I want instant gratification and not have to wait for the top to break in. I'm not so concerned about set up as I can do that myself.<br /> <br /> I've A/B'd them with offerings from the T company and my personal T guitars and I'm not convinced.<br /> <br /> Why do I still want one? The GAS continues until I find the "one" that speaks to me. (or thru me)



stratcowboy

Contributing Member
**********
**

USA/Taos, NM

Oct 26th, 2017 03:08 PM        

"I just don't like they way they come out of the box. They sound like cardboard to me."<br /> <br /> I agree--or at least in my limited experience.<br /> <br /> The other day I had a chance to head to the "big city." I don't get out of the woods much up here. But I went into a very good shop/dealer that carries Martin, Taylor, Eastman, etc. Some beautiful guitars to look at. My frame of reference is my Guild F47RC...a high-end Guild with excellent richness and projection and very balanced tone. I played several Martins (HD-28, D-35, and another). Played an Eastman as well as strummed a few Taylors (that's as far as I got). They all had that boxy/cardboard-y tone to them. Really disappointing. I was stunned actually. My Guild was so far-and-away superior in tonality it just wasn't even a valid comparison. I guess I should have tried the Martin D-42 they had; maybe that was better. But I was so dismayed at what I had heard to that point in time, that I didn't have the patience to try any more.<br /> <br /> I just figured it was me...



Chris Greene

FDP Host

Idaho, USA

Nine mile skid on a ten mile ride
Oct 26th, 2017 03:21 PM        

I think it is just you guys. New Martins sound like "cardboard"? Well, I'd played a bunch that were sent to me when I started this thread. There were none I didn't like but the two I bought were the two I thought sounded best (and were lookers as well). But, as they say, horses for courses. Not everyone likes Martin guitars. Personally, for acoustics, it's hard for me to like anything else, especially the oft loved Taylors.



Hammond101

Contributing Member
**********
*

So. Cal. USA

Oct 26th, 2017 03:52 PM        

That's exactly it Chris. I was sitting in the acoustic quiet room playing that D-18E. I really liked it. Strum, finger style. I plugged it in and liked it even more. I pulled down a Taylor 914ce that was hanging right in front of me and wow. It had clarity the Martin lacked, it had better projection and was louder it still had great bottom. Granted, it a more expensive guitar. I came back on another day with my personal 814ce and compared to all the Martin dreads in stock. I was happy with what I already own. Other than bling it sounded like the 914ce.<br /> <br /> Still in search of a Martin I really enjoy. The D35 of all D35s got away from me. I want "that" tone.



Chris Greene

FDP Host

Idaho, USA

Nine mile skid on a ten mile ride
Oct 26th, 2017 04:41 PM        

Well, good luck but you might want to be looking for an old Martin instead of a new one. There's a quality to the '72 D-18 I recently got that is different than my two modern rosewood Martins but I attribute it to 45 year old wood and mahogany. It's a guitar without the typical rosewood overtones which is neither good or bad, just different.<br /> <br /> The 70's D-18's (and 28's and 35's) have the age but not the prices.



Hammond101

Contributing Member
**********
*

So. Cal. USA

Oct 26th, 2017 05:46 PM        

I am certainly open to any Martin dread that pleases my ears and is fairly priced. It doesn't have to be new. Honestly a well cared for used instrument would be preferred. There seems to be many 18-35 offerings on the bay and reverb but I need to play them. Maybe I should start asking at local pawn shops. You just never know what got away from some tweeker and is hidden in the back.<br /> <br /> I think I'm going to give JR a call up in Utah and have him keep an eye out. I trust his judgment and know I could do much worse elsewhere. The D-35 that got away and really tripped my trigger was mid 80s, go figure. That was the guitar that started the journey a couple of years back.<br /> <br /> To be fair, my 814ce is now over 10 years old, a mid '07. It has been the last 3-4 years I have really enjoyed the tone. I always liked it but now it is outstanding. It has a smoothness it never had before. The GC6e is a 2011 and is just as good but better at finger style and being a concert body not as bold. The 312ce is meh but a good traveler and sailboat box.



6L6

Contributing Member
**********
**********
*****

San Francisco, CA

Oct 30th, 2017 12:28 PM        

I recently bought a one-owner, pristine condition 1970 Martin D-28 off my local CL for just $1500. It sounds so good I took it to Gryphon for a total tuneup. New stainless steel frets, neck reset, and K & K pup.<br /> <br /> The quality of the wood is just outstanding. While my ears usually favor dreads with FSSB, this sounds terrific too.<br /> <br /> There IS a difference in 70âs wood and Itâs all good.<br /> <br /> 6



Hammond101

Contributing Member
**********
*

So. Cal. USA

Oct 30th, 2017 12:59 PM        

I played a brand new HD-28 last Friday at a GC in San Bernadino. It was knocked out of the running as it had display damage and they were not willing to deal much at all. It had a pretty big "worm" mark in the top between the pickguard and the lower waist, a good 4-5 inches long. It also had scratches on the side on the lower waist area as if someone played it resting on a pile of keys in their pocket.<br /> <br /> Really too bad it was tore up. It really sounded good. I will most likely find something used. I'm in no hurry.



Chris Greene

FDP Host

Idaho, USA

Nine mile skid on a ten mile ride
Oct 30th, 2017 01:06 PM        

I liked the HD-28's a lot. I only wish they'd use ivoroid binding vs. the cheapish looking Bolatron. I'm not completely sold on FSSB bracing as it emphasizes the bass at the exclusion of the trebles.



Copyright 1999-2003 Fender Discussion Page, LLC. Visit the web site at http://www.fenderforum.com