FDP Forum / What Should My Grandson Start On?/ 7 messages in thread.

1 to 7 of 7 shown.


6L6

Contributing Member
*********

Lago, CA

"Dyin' ain't much of a livin'...
Nov 30th, 2010 07:48 PM        

My 5 yr old grandson loves everything about music. While he can't finger guitar chords just yet, he loves strumming on his mini-Strat and does so in perfect time.<br /> <br /> We'd like to get him started on piano and he's bugging us to do so. Should we invest in a std piano or would an electric keyboard be a better choice? He will be taking professional lessons.<br /> <br /> Thanks for any suggestions you can offer!<br /> <br /> 6



garp

Contributing Member
*******

Connecticut USA

Good, fresh things every day of the year
Dec 1st, 2010 06:49 AM        

IMHO, investing in a real acoustic piano for a 5-year-old would not be a prudent decision. While you *may* have a budding Rachmaninoff here, you may also have a child who could conceivably lose a lot of interest in music just a year or two from now.<br /> <br /> To mitigate the financial risk for grandma & grandpa, I&#8217;d opt instead for an electric keyboard. If possible, get an 88-key model with full-sized keys and hammer action that simulates the feel of an acoustic piano. It may involve a bit more &#8220;work&#8221; for those little 5-year-old fingers to make music on this type of keyboard. However, should your grandson decide to proceed with more formalized training on an actual acoustic piano as he gets older, he&#8217;ll already be &#8220;at home&#8221; on the instrument.



zeprin

Contributing Member
******

Day After Day,

Alone On A Hill...
Dec 1st, 2010 07:44 AM        

Scan CL & the Want Ads for real acoustic piano's.<br /> You should be able to find a decent one for anything from FREE(!) to a couple of hundred dollars. Which is like Half the price, or less, than that of a good electric keyboard. And it would probably be in better shape for the price.<br /> <br /> <br /> z



6L6

Contributing Member
*********

Lago, CA

"Dyin' ain't much of a livin'...
Dec 1st, 2010 08:39 AM        

Thanks for the advice above.<br /> <br /> I probably should have added that I see my grandson's interest in keyboards as being directed at learning to play good Rock & Roll keyboards, not classical piano music. Does that make a difference?<br /> <br /> 6



shoebox22

Contributing Member
**********
*

Las Vegas, NV

Margaritaville in the Mojave - FDP Jam
Dec 1st, 2010 10:09 AM        

As a former piano teacher, I'd recommend picking up an old but servicable studio, spinet, or upright, but be sure to get a full keyboard.<br /> <br /> So long as he starts on an accoustic piano, or, at the minimum, a good electric with weighted keys, he'll be able to play anything he wants as he grows into his music.<br /> <br /> My recommendation, especially at that age, is the accoustic so that he learns all the basics and isn't tempted to "play" with all the extra bells and whistles. Once he has the "fingers" and can read music, he can branch to whatever.<br /> <br /> Don't be surprised if he loses interest between about 9-13 and then wants to go back. It happens a lot with budding musicians and so long as you don't push it, if there's a real interest, they'll enjoy it more if it's their idea.<br /> <br /> Off the soapbox. Enjoy!



6L6

Contributing Member
*********

Lago, CA

"Dyin' ain't much of a livin'...
Dec 1st, 2010 04:43 PM        

Many thanks again to all who responded!<br /> <br /> 6



JazzMastaJim



USA

Rockin' the Delaware Valley
Dec 3rd, 2010 02:29 PM        

shoebox22 said, "So long as he starts on an accoustic piano, or, at the minimum, a good electric with weighted keys, he'll be able to play anything he wants as he grows into his music."<br /> <br /> That's just what I was going to say. Weighted keys are important for learning to play properly with dynamics, etc. For a new student, an acoustic piano would be best, but if you go the electronic route, stay away from semi-weighted or unweighted keys.



Copyright 1999-2003 Fender Discussion Page, LLC. Visit the web site at http://www.fenderforum.com